The Rare Blue Cardinal: Myth or Reality?

A bird that looks like a blue Cardinal

In the enchanting world of birdwatching, cardinal birds have long captivated enthusiasts with their vibrant colors, and among its many species, the appeal of a blue cardinal has sparked a lot of curiosity. 

The mention of mythical blue cardinals has become a subject of many discussions and debates, leaving many to question its existence. 

To uncover the truth behind the blue cardinal rumor, we will explore the bird world and the distinct colors of cardinal birds. 

This article will shed light on whether rare blue cardinals are indeed a reality or simply an enchanting tale passed down through the ages.

Are There Blue Cardinals?

Bird that looks like blue Cardinal in the morning light

There is no scientific evidence supporting the existence of naturally blue cardinals. The vibrant blue color attributed to these birds is often the result of photo manipulation, lighting conditions, or a rare genetic mutation called leucism. Leucism can cause patches of white or pale coloration in birds, but it does not produce true blue feathers.

True cardinals are known for their bright red plumage. However, female Northern cardinals sport a pale brown color with reddish tints on their wings, tail, and crest. 

Cardinals are found across North America. While many blue cardinal sightings have been reported, the evidence proving the existence of blue cardinals remains inconclusive. 

Some articles and websites have overstated the myth of blue cardinals, leading to confusion among enthusiasts.

Birdwatchers are encouraged to be cautious of unverified claims and to rely on credible sources when identifying species of birds.

As an avid birdwatcher with a deep passion for cardinal birds, I’ve had the privilege of observing various members of this vibrant Northern cardinal bird family. 

While I’ve encountered a large number of colored cardinals throughout my birdwatching journey, one experience has eluded me — the elusive blue cardinal. 

Despite numerous birdwatching expeditions and dedicated searches, I have yet to see a blue cardinal. While some may claim to have sighted this rare type of cardinal, I remain cautious, knowing the importance of scientific evidence in confirming such an extraordinary find.

Blue Birds Most Commonly Mistaken for Blue Cardinals

When it comes to birdwatching, the allure of spotting a rare blue cardinal can be captivating. However, the truth remains that a true blue cardinal does not exist. 

Nevertheless, there are several gorgeous blue birds that look like cardinals but belong to different species.

Blue Jay

Blue Jay

One might mistake the Blue Jay for a blue cardinal since Blue Jays are also common in North America.

Both male and female Blue Jays boast stunning blue plumage on their wings and tail, but their crest and back are a mix of blue, white, and black. 

Blue Jays are larger than cardinals and have distinctive black collars around their necks. They are known for their loud calls and enjoy visiting bird feeders in residential areas.

Blue Grosbeak

Blue Grosbeak

Another bird commonly mistaken for a blue cardinal is the Blue Grosbeak. These birds have a deep blue hue with brown wings and a large silver bill. 

Blue Grosbeaks and cardinals also inhabit different terrains. The former prefers open habitats like grasslands and farmlands. Their song is a mix of warbles and trills, which helps distinguish them from blue cardinals.

Tufted Titmouse

Tufted Titmouse

Though not entirely blue, the Tufted Titmouse can be mistaken for blue cardinals because of their blue-gray plumage on the wings and tail.

These small birds have a cute tufted crest on their heads and a white face. They are common in woodlands and backyards, where they are fond of visiting bird feeders for seeds and nuts.

If you are curious about other gray birds, like the Tufted Titmouse, you can learn more about them in this article.


Pyrrhuloxia with bluish tint

A blue cardinal might also be mistaken for a Pyrrhuloxia, also known as the Desert Cardinal. This is due to the mix of blue and red hues in their plumage.

Like cardinals, Pyrrhuloxia birds have a prominent head crest but are mostly grayish-brown with a touch of blue on the wings and tail. 

Although part of the cardinal family, Pyrrhuloxias inhabit arid regions in the southwestern United States and Mexico.

Indigo Buntings

Indigo Buntings

The Indigo Bunting is a blue-colored bird that looks like a blue cardinal. However, these species are smaller than cardinals, and they have thinner beaks. 

Male indigo buntings are bright blue all over, while females are brown with hints of blue. They prefer brushy habitats and are commonly seen during the breeding season.

Florida Scrub Jay

Florida Scrub Jay

A Florida Scrub Jay might be confused with blue cardinals due to their blue wings and tails. However, they have a grayish-blue head and back, and their underparts are pale gray.

These gray birds exist mainly in Florida and inhabit scrubland and oak forests.

Steller’s Jay

Stellers Jay

If you think you have spotted a blue cardinal, you might have seen a steller’s jay. Similar to cardinals, this species is found in western North America. They are known to have vibrant blue feathers on their wings and tails.

However, they are also popular for their black crest and head, which easily distinguishes them from blue cardinals.

The distinct crests in birds like those of Steller’s Jays not only aid in identification but may also be used by these birds to attract mates, among other functions.

Steller’s Jays are also known for their bold personalities and loud calls.

Red-Crested Cardinal

Red crested Cardinal with blue tint

The Red-crested Cardinal might be mistaken for a blue cardinal due to its striking blue color. However, their name gives away the crucial difference: a bright red crest on their heads. 

These birds are native to South America and are not closely related to the true cardinals found in North America.

Cardinals in Specific Lighting

The stunning red plumage of cardinals can appear different under various lighting conditions, adding to their allure for birdwatchers. 

In bright sunlight, male cardinals showcase their vibrant red color, making them stand out against the green foliage. The sunlight enhances their beauty, creating a captivating sight in gardens and parks.

During overcast days or in the shade, cardinals may seem less vibrant, with their red feathers appearing darker or slightly duller. The lack of direct sunlight can soften the intensity of their color. 

However, even under these conditions, the contrast between their red body and black facial mask remains striking.

When viewed under the soft glow of sunrise or sunset, cardinals may exhibit a warm, almost fiery appearance. 

The golden hues of the sun’s rays can cast a magical glow on the plumage of this backyard bird, making them a sight to behold during these tranquil moments.

The lighting conditions can significantly influence the perception of a cardinal’s appearance.

However, regardless of the lighting, their distinctive features and beautiful melodies continue to captivate bird enthusiasts year-round.

Frequently Asked Questions

Bird that looks like a blue Cardinal up close

Are Blue Jays and Blue Cardinals the Same?

Blue Jays and blue cardinals are not the same. They belong to different bird species. 

Blue Jays are larger birds with a mix of blue, white, and black on their bodies, whereas blue cardinals, often referred to as “blue” cardinals, do not actually exist as a separate species. 

Are Female Cardinals Blue?

Female cardinals do not display the vibrant red plumage that male cardinals are famous for. Instead, female cardinals have a more subdued appearance with a primarily brown body and hints of red on their wings, crest, and tail. 

Their duller coloration serves as camouflage while they incubate eggs or care for their young.

Are Baby Cardinals Blue?

Baby cardinals, also known as cardinal chicks, are not blue when they hatch. They have a pinkish, naked appearance with closed eyes. As they grow, their feathers start to develop, and their coloration gradually changes. 

Male juvenile cardinals begin to show hints of red on their feathers, while female juveniles retain a more neutral brownish color until they mature.

If you have ever thought you saw the mysterious blue cardinal, we invite you to share your experiences and thoughts in the comments below. You can also ask any questions you may have about these birds.

Leave a Comment

You may also like